Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Hubris as Strategy


Sometimes advertisers are so caught up in the competitive spirit that they slam the competition but forget to sell their own product.  The recent Jaguar commercial is an example of hubris in advertising.  The ad makes no claims, creates no unique selling proposition, has no distinctive brand attributes.  The ad simply says that Jaguar is the fastest growing luxury brand ... and that the competition is quaking in their boots.  What's worse, the artful production uses effects (like the headlamps of the car creating a mini light show) that actually obscure the product.  

I'm sure when the commercial was screened, the execs in the conference room were high-five-ing when the ad claims that Jaguar is growing faster than the competition.  I'm also willing to bet that the consumer will simply yawn. 

The Importance of Being Global


I was recently interviewed for a University of Hawaii publication on international education.  Here's what I said:




Q.  You’ve been an advocate for international education at University of Hawai‘i.  What prompted your interest?


A.  It’s no secret that “the world is flat.”  The world has never been so connected … by technology, communications, and commerce.  Success in the future is going to belong to those who understand this and are able to work in a multi-national environment.  If you look at large corporations, they’re all multi-national and more and more of their revenues are coming from areas outside of their headquarters base.  If you look at research and development, you’re seeing more innovation and new patents coming from emerging economies rather than just the highly industrialized nations. 


Q.  What kind of background does it take to succeed in this “flat world?” 


A.  First of all, it requires an open mind and a willingness to look beyond your comfort level.  In that sense, I would say that curiosity about the big, wide world is something I would look for when hiring someone in this day and age.  An educational background in international subjects, knowledge of several languages, and travel abroad all are indicators of that mindset and all of those things help promote that curiosity about the big, wide world. 

A Meeting with the Abu Dhabi Tourism Authority

Beyond that, there are certain skills that can provide the basis for success in the global   A background in the social sciences is a great foundation for understanding different cultures.  A background in international business provides an understanding of how business is conducted in different parts of the world.  Language skills, of course, are always useful.
community.


Understanding different cultures and being able to adapt products, programs and ideas to fit into them is often a critical skill.  When I worked for a Pizza Hut franchisee that was developing Pizza Hut restaurants in Taiwan, the company started by trying to sell pizza the way that worked in the U.S.:  a great tasting product with an Italian heritage.  In Taiwan, though, there is little appreciation for an Italian heritage.  After struggling with the introduction of Pizza Hut for a while, the company finally made some changes.  They changed the toppings on the pizza to include options like squid.  And they changed the message to be more culturally appropriate.  The message was all about sharing food with friends, which is a natural part of the pizza experience, rather than focusing on the pizza itself.  After those changes, sales really blossomed. 


Q.  What about language?


As I said, being able to speak multiple languages is often a key to success in the global marketplace.  English has been the standard, but more and more people are studying Mandarin to be able to operate in an era when China is becoming such an important player on the world stage. 


There’s an old joke that goes like this:  If you speak three languages, you’re tri-lingual.  If you speak two languages, you’re bi-lingual.  If you speak one language, you’re American.  That has to change.

Even if you’re not fluent, having some basic language skills demonstrates that you care enough about other cultures to at least try to communicate with them in their language.

Q.  What are the possibilities for Hawai‘i in terms of tapping into global opportunities?
For one thing, Hawai‘i has the University of Hawai‘i and its system of colleges.  Given our diverse culture in Hawai‘i and the highly regarded international programs at the University of Hawai‘i, we should naturally be a magnet for international education. 


And, of course, Hawai‘i has a well-respected global brand in tourism.  Tourism is a trillion dollar industry that is expected to continue to grow rapidly fueled by the revolutions in technology, transportation and economic development.  In addition to all of the economic benefits of tourism, the industry naturally exposes people to different cultures and ideas from around the world and, in that regard, it can really be an instrument for global understanding.
Q.  How can Hawai‘i become a better global player?


A.  Over the years, different people have suggested that Hawai‘i is a natural center for global or multi-national businesses, meetings and other activities but that hasn’t happened in a big way.  Part of the rationale for this thinking in the past was that Hawai‘i’s geographic location would naturally make it attractive as a global player.  Long range aircraft, telecommunications technology and the internet have diminished that geographical advantage; however, there are some significant advantages that Hawai‘i has now – or could further develop – that could make Hawai‘i a significant global player. 


One of these advantages is international education.  The University of Hawai‘i and Hawai‘i Pacific University already have a significant number of international students and some extraordinary international programs.  And, of course, there is the East-West Center.  Graduates from these programs often return to their home countries with a familiarity about Hawai‘i, the University and the multi-cultural society here that can make Hawai‘i top-of-mind as a place open to global thinking. 


Another advantage that is still based on Hawai‘i’s geographic location is the ability to host international meetings and events.  As more and more companies are becoming global, it no longer makes sense for sales meetings, product rollouts, conferences and other events to be exclusively scheduled on the US mainland.  Holding these events in Hawai‘i encourages better attendance from Asia and, incidentally, highlights Hawai‘i as a place for international business.  The enormous investment in time and resources to host the APEC (Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation) forum was intended to showcase Hawai‘i as a place where East and West can have a productive meeting.  We need to continue to take advantage of the publicity and goodwill that came out of APEC. 


And, of course, we should lead from our strengths.  Tourism is the dominant industry in Hawai‘i and Hawai‘i is known the world over for its tourism expertise.  We can take advantage of the power of the Hawai‘i tourism “brand” by exporting our expertise in resort design, hospitality education, sustainable tourism practices and other consulting services.  

Q.  How can UH compete to attract more international students?


A.  It isn’t difficult.   It just requires making international initiatives a priority.  There are many opportunities to recruit international students through enrollment fairs and other activities abroad.  There are also other marketing activities including advertising, social media, and specialized websites that can be developed.  It just takes time, effort and money.


Another approach is to work cooperatively with the state Department of Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT) and other colleges and universities in Hawai‘i to develop a marketing campaign promoting the state as a great place for international education.  The individual colleges, then, would benefit from the interest in the Hawai‘i brand and promote their own institutions more effectively.  DBEDT has done this on a limited basis in the past and understands the economic impact that international students contribute to the state. 

 

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Logos: The Subtle (and sometimes not-so-subtle) Evolution of Great Logos


A logo is an essential element of a brand's personality.  As such, even the little things about a logo say a lot about it.   This article takes you through the logic of logo development for some really big brands:  what wasn't right about the "before" and what worked with the "after" rendition of the logo.

What's wrong about the old WAL*MART logo.  Click and find out.

Wednesday, March 26, 2014

Blah, Blah, Blah. Generic Messages Are Just That


Click here to take a look at this spoof on contemporary corporate brand advertising.  If it weren't so true, it would be funny. 

Sunday, March 16, 2014

Customer Empathy


I have been watching the growth of Chinese visitors to Hawaii ... and have been advocating that the hospitality industry do much more to understand their needs.  I've heard from tour operators and others that, to properly service this market, hotels need to have Mandarin speaking staff members available 24/7, include amenities that are preferred by the Chinese (i.e.loose tea in addition to coffee makers in the room), include Mandarin television channels in the in-room entertainment system, and more. 

Intellectually, I understood the importance of these considerations.  Recently, however, they came home to me viscerally when I stayed in a hotel in Morocco. 

The first issue I encountered was the need to make a local telephone call late at night (my suitcase had been lost and I was trying to track it down).  There were no instructions for making calls in the room, so I called the operator and asked (in English) how I could get an outside line.  The operator obviously spoke very little English.  She first said "you must call from your room."  I said "yes, but how do I get an outside line?"  She said, "I don't understand."  I said, "how do I make a telephone call?"  She repeated, "I don't understand."  And hung up. 

I was also trying to follow a breaking news story (the disappearance of the Malaysian aircraft). Once again, there were no in-room materials for the television.  I was able to find CNN, but it was in French.  It was frustrating to try to follow the news without access to a channel in a language I understand.  (Thank goodness for the internet ... it was my English-language window to the world). 

So now I have experienced the issues and challenges that I only imagined before.  Taking a walk in the customer's shoes is a real eye-opener.

Friday, February 28, 2014

Farmed and Dangerous: An "Unbranding" Story by Chipotle


It's not for everyone ... but here's a link to how Chipotle does guerrilla marketing via internet video. 


Sunday, February 23, 2014

Stretching a Brand Beyond Its Limits: Porsche


While driving along, I spotted a Porsche SUV the other day.  I had heard that Porsche was making a sports utility vehicle, but I had never seen one before.  It matched my expectations:  a vehicle that was way out of character for a sports car brand. 

The Porsche 997 G3T (top) and the Porsche SUV.  Do you see the family resemblence?
I'm sure that the folks at Porsche had meetings in which they analyzed the SUV market and evaluated the generous margins that go along with manufacturing SUVs.  But apparently in those meetings, no strong voice spoke up to say "this just doesn't fit the Porsche brand." 

I obviously don't work for Porsche, but I imagine the brand is all wrapped up in images and fantasies about speed, youthful fantasy and testosterone.  I can't imagine that the brand fits well with a type of vehicle that is associated with taking the kids to soccer practice. 

Many car manufacturers want to have an SUV in their lineup exactly because they are profitable and desirable for a segment of their customers.  But for me, it's easier for brands like Mercedes and Volvo to include an SUV in the lineup (even though the fit isn't perfect) than for Porsche ... because Porsche doesn't have a brand that stands for anything as mundane as taking the kids to soccer practice.  To take this to an extreme ... do you think Rolls Royce should have an SUV in its lineup?  Hmmmm.  I doubt that would make sense.